Lilla Crawford (left) is Shelby, Olivia Finkelstein (center) is Beth and Varinique “V” Davis (right) is Nell in the West Coast premiere of Kimberly Belflower’s John Proctor Is the Villain at ACT’s Toni Rembe Theater through Dec. 13. Photo by Kevin Berne
If I had been exposed to Kimberly Belflower’s John Proctor Is the Villain in high school instead of Arthur Miller’s The Crucible, things might have been different.
A raging hit since its runs on Broadway and in London, John Proctor is a play about many things, among them being a tormented teen, being a tormented teen circa 2018 at the dawn of the #MeToo era and being a tormented teen who recognizes that The Crucible is bullshit.
You don’t have to be an expert in Miller’s 1953 tragedy, which used the Salem witchunts as an allegory for McCarthy’s Red Scare, to appreciate what Belflower is doing in her vehement takedown of its toxic masculinity, but it’s all the more delicious if you do. What you do need to know is that being a teenage girl in 2018 comes with more awareness of the world, its imbalances and its heinous power games, but in truth it’s not all that different from being a girl in 1953 or, for that matter, in 1692, the era of the actual witch hunts. And that is fuuuuuuucking depressing.
What’s not depressing is the magnificently energized, blazingly ferocious production of John Proctor Is the Villain now at American Conservatory Theater’s Toni Rembe Theater (a co-production with Seattle Rep and Center Theatre Group in Los Angeles).
Lilla Crawford is Shelby, a wildly intelligent teen in a small-town Georgia high school in John Proctor Is the Villain.Photo by Kevin Berne
Director Jess McLeod creates a crucible, if you will, into which are fed all the ingredients for combustion. You have an overtaxed public school system in small-town Georgia forcing a literature teacher to lead six weeks of mandatory sex ed. You have a tight-knit student body who have known each other for as long as they can remember, and all the friendships, romances and grudges that entails. And you have a cultural moment when women are fighting back against monsters like Harvey Weinstein, and the high school girls are paying close attention.
Seems the perfect time for Carter Smith (Kyle Harris), the “cool” English teacher everyone loves, to teach The Crucible. It’s a play, he says, that features one of his favorite heroes ever, John Proctor, a man defiantly proud of his good name who had an affair with the 17-year-old girl brought in to help his wife take care of their children. So much of the play’s hysteria and chaos stems from Proctor’s desire to keep the world from knowing about his affair. Perhaps accountability hadn’t been invented yet in the 17th century (or the mid-20th century, apparently).
Though there are only seven students in the class (five girls, two boys), there’s just enough variety to keep the situation highly charged. Beth (Olivia Finkelstein) is an overachieving teacher’s pet with a penchant for apologizing. She is also the driving force behind her school’s feminism club. Her best friend is Ivy (Stevie Allen), whose father is facing a #MeToo reckoning of his own, prompting some of her friends to admit that his back rubs during sleepovers made them uncomfortable.
The cast of John Proctor Is the Villain at ACT includes (from left) Kaylee Kaneshiro as Raeylnn, Olivia Finkelstein as Beth, Kyle Harris as Mr. Smith, Varinique “V” Davis as Nell and Mario Houle as Lee. Photo by Kevin Berne
Raelynn (Kaylee Kaneshiro) is in the throes of heartbreak. Her boyfriend of many years, the doofus Lee (Mario Houle), has cheated on her – and not just with anyone, but with her best friend Shelby (Lilla Crawford), who mysteriously disappeared from school and has only just returned. The one person in class without any previous entanglements is the bright and sensible Nell (Varinique “V” Davis), a recent transplant from Atlanta.
Every character takes a journey, and Belflower uses The Crucible to ignite debate and protest and righteous indignation. As he introduces the play, the English teacher says that part of why we turn to literature is that it reflects so much of what is happening in the world today. He has no idea what he’s in for as the young women, notably Shelby and Raelynn, see through him and Miller and Proctor and begin to seize the power that is rightfully theirs as human beings on this planet.
At just over 100 minutes, the play establishes vivid characters almost immediately by letting the teenagers speak with humor, intelligence, vulnerability and angst. Within the confines of a perfectly detailed classroom set by Kate Noll, they revel in the easy communication of their shared pop culture, pulling Taylor Swift, Beyoncé, Harry Styles and, most importantly, Lorde into the way they express themselves. The cast (which also includes Erika Vetter as a guidance counselor and Ameer Ali as the non-doofus Mason) crackles with vitality. The actors stay grounded even as they ratchet up an intensity that builds to an explosive, possibly cataclysmic, conclusion. There’s a line of dialogue that rings like a prayer: “One day maybe the new world we were promised will actually be new. One day maybe the men in charge won't be in charge anymore. One day we can dance in the forest.”
As a teenager, I was too meek and careful to dance in the forest. I can’t change that, but I could feel my younger self of more than 40 years ago savoring every moment of empowerment and release forged by the young women of John Proctor Is the Villain.
FOR MORE INFORMATION
Kimberly Belflower’s John Proctor Is the Villain continues through Dec. 13 at American Conservatory Theater’s Toni Rembe Theater, 415 Geary St., San Francisco. Running time: One hour and 45 minutes (no intermission). Tickets are $28-$207 (subject to change). Call 415-749-2228 or visit act-sf.org/villain.